The Twist – Emilie’s Prediction/Suggestion
So, in my Odd and Random – 5/21/10 post, I linked to an interview with some of the All-Stars where Lauren predicted that the SYTYCD powers-that-be still had some surprises in store for everybody, including the All-Stars themselves. I hinted that I had an idea of what one such twist could be.
I know for sure a lot of you will hate this idea. Let’s see if some of you love it.
What if…
What if the contestants/All-Stars were required to re-dance one of the All-Stars’ iconic dances.
This is what I mean by this.
One week, Twitch and his partner have to re-dance “Mercy,” choreographed by Mia Michaels -
And his former partner, Comfort and her NEW partner re-dance “Forever,” choreographed by Dave Scott -
Neil and his partner re-dance “Sweet Dreams,” choreographed by Mandy Moore -
Meanwhile, Lauren and a new partner re-dance “Night of the Dancing Flame,” choreographed by Wade Robson –
And maybe Dominic and a new contestant re-dance “Ain’t No Sunshine,” choreographed by Tony & Melanie -
Allison might re-dance “Why,” choreographed by Tyce Diorio with a new partner -
Kathryn might re-dance “2 Steps,” choreographed by Stacey Tookey with a new contestant -
Another week, Courtney and her partner have to re-dance “The Garden,” choreographed by Sonya -
Meanwhile, Mark and his partner would have to re-dance “Bleeding Love,” choreographed by Nappytabs -
Anya and a new partner might re-dance “You and Me,” choreographed by Hunter Johnson –
And Pasha and a new contestant might re-dance “In the Morning,” choreographed by Dave Scott -
Or Ade might dance “This Woman’s Work, also choreographed by Tyce Diorio, with a new partner -
P.S. If you hate the idea of “iconic performances” being re-danced, watch this clip of Charlie and Robbie of SYTYCD UK doing Tyce’s “This Woman’s Work.” It was performed by Charlie and Robbie not too long after Melissa and Ade and it still managed to move me:
I guess this last one also counts as a Cross Country Comparison, a la Marianya.
And P.S.S. Check out this video that some amateur (high school?) dancers did replicating Chelsea and Mark’s “Bleeding Love” performance. I love that SYTYCD influences folks like this!



Hmm…I’m thinking probably not. As much as I’d like to see some of these iconic dances. I’d be ok if they did some of these on the results shows. No judging, just looking back and loving.
Hmm I dont like the idea of recreating iconic dances with only one new person. I dont think I would mind two new dancers. Honestly I dont want to see Mark dance bleeding love with anyone else but Chelsie. I agree with John about a just for fun thing not judging.
@John & Amanda: I agree that they should be non-competition, because they’d be judged on some level by how memorable the routine was the first go round.
But…it can’t be an accident that so many of the All-Stars are former partners. They HAVE TO dance together. Right?
This could work… only if, just like in Season 6, they do an introduction episode where it’s not a competition and the dancers are in no danger of being eliminated. It would help to establish the Season 7 dancers being abreast with the previous contestants while recreating the same nostalgic emotions and impact that have made all of us love the past seasons’ dancers and this show. It would be the perfect touchstone to hint the start of an amazing season.
I liked the Bleeding Love video you posted. I am pretty sure that it is from the Philippines. Talk about the power of the internet.
I’m glad you liked the video, Karolyn. It was a late find, after I’d originally posted.
Speaking of the introduction episode, does anyone know if they are doing one this season? Of all the S6 changes, that was the one that seemed to get nearly universal positive feedback.
You know, Kevin, I certainly hope so. It seems like a foolish thing not to have a Meet the Top 10 after the success of last season’s (and SYTYCD AU’s) Meet the Top 20. I found this which seems to indicate that they will have one, but I don’t know how reliable it is.
I”m pretty sure I remember Nigel saying something, somewhere that they are. I can’t remember exactly where. But, I’m 90% positive they’re having one.
I’m agreeing with Dennis, play these videos during the “Meet the Top 10″ episode, if you can’t get all the original pairs together, though we could hypothetically see: The Garden, Forever, Night of the Dancing Flame and Ain’t No Sunshine since all these pairs are All-Stars together. I’m with everyone saying that it would be too weird seeing one half of the pair doing it with someone new.
I think it would be a great way to show how the show has grown over the past 5 years. Plus, you know the long time fans would LOVE it since we loved seeing The Bench, Ramalama and the Hummingbird and the Flower during the 100th episode, and the results show where they brought back this past year’s Emmy nominees: the Door, Silence, Bleeding Love, and A Los Amigos. Get on it Nigel! I think this would be awesome.
[...] looooove that they’re going to have the All-Stars re-dance some of their iconic routines. It’s like they heard all our talk and they listened to us. Makes me start thinking about what other routines we might see in the coming [...]