Season 8 Finale Part 2 Thoughts and Discussion
Here are my live thoughts and a space for you to start and join in on the discussion. Spoiler space since I’ll be talking live and relatively uncensored…
Not a big fan of Sonya’s Top 20/Top 4 group routine. I wish she’d stop using District 78 songs (sorry!) because I find them really cold and unemotional and hard to relate to. The routine was really disorienting since the dancers kept coming in and out, on and off the stage. I kept thinking I spotted the All-Stars. Am I wrong about that??
As for the judges’ panel tonight, I am SO GLAD Jesse Tyler Ferguson is back and SO GLAD Katie Holmes is gone. I’ll miss Kenny Oretga, though. I’d rather have him than Robin Antin, but overall this panel is a really, really good one. It was sweet to see Mel crying during the judges’ words of advice and support, especially Sonya’s.
Seeing all 4 of them lined up together, I just wondered – is this the most ethnically diverse Top 4 we’ve had on the U.S. show? Kinda cool.
I’m glad Mary chose the “Fool of Me” routine withΒ Sasha and Kent. It’s one of my favorites (it’s even on my list) and I really enjoyed seeing it again. I can’t get over how strong and light they both were, but how heavy the “story” and acting was. Love it.
The Mary and Nigel “romance” segment was silly and a good chance for me to catch up on my posts. :)-
I considered Nigel’s pick, Melanie and Marko’s Nappytabs routine “I Got You,” and I really loved seeing it again. Same is true for Robin’s pick, the Mandy Moore “heist” routine with Tadd and LoFro. I almost put both of them on my favorites list. It was nice to see it again without the hat malfunction. π
Cat cracked me up when there was mic/feedback issues and she said gremlins were in the studio trying to find out the finale results. π That’s why she’s Emmy-nominated.
AND, I almost picked the Miranda/Robert Nappytabs “woodpecker” routine, too. These have all been really good picks.
I DID pick Cat’s favorite – Tyce’s Top 8 circus routine. LOOOOOOOOOVED that one!! So nice to see it again, even if it wasn’t live again.
It was SO COOL to see the SYTYCD UK champ Matt Flint tap with Jess and Nick Young from this season. It made me aware of a couple of things. 1. I haven’t seen that season of SYTYCD UK and I’ll have to fix that. 2. Nick Young didn’t stay on the show nearly long enough. He should’ve had more of a shot. I agree with Nigel that that was the most exciting tap routine I’ve ever seen.
Mary made me so happy when she picked the Melanie and Neil “Total Eclipse of the Heart” routine. Even if there were a few missteps, they still have the best chemistry. I hope they get cast as Baby and Johnny in the new Dirty Dancing. π
I enjoyed seeing Marko and Allison re-dance their Sonya contemporary a lot and it seemed to resonate with Marko’s life and death experience in a way I wasn’t paying attention to the first time.
Really, really loved seeing Sonay’s Top 10 Girls Geisha routine again. Sick is right. Some routines just have their own attitude and this is one of those. Lol
Not surprised that Tadd is #4. He did a phenomenal job this season and I was really glad to be reminded about how many different styles he picked up and did really well with.
Really loved watching Ashley and Chris do “Please Mr. Jailer” again. Soo good, and a good choice for Lil C.
The best part about the Glee Movie 3D segment was how Heather, Naya and Harry scared the Top 4 into thinking they’d have to sing and dance.Β π Also and watching Tadd interview Ryan Murphy and Melanie ask Heather about auditioning for SYTYCD.
So glad somebody chose Christopher Scott’s “Misty Blue” with Sasha and Twitch. Of course it was Nigel, but I don’t care because I got to see it again. Sooooo good, as Cat said, kinda growling. π Just like Cat, “like a proper geek,” I have re-watched this routine many, many, many times. It might just be my favorite of the season.
Sonya picked Christopher Scott’s Top 10 Guys routine and I loved re-watching that. I realized Alexander had died his hair and that might’ve been why I was thinking I saw All-Stars in the opening routine. Lol. :)-
I just wish Jesse’s pick, Caitlynn’s Argentine Tango with Pasha, had been live. I know, I know, maybe Pasha wasn’t available and almost definitely there wasn’t enough time, but it was nice to see again, regardless. One of my favorites.
Soooo glad Mary picked Melanie and Marko’s first routine together, “Turn to Stone.” So good to see again, even if they weren’t painted (not enough time, I’m sure). It was ESPECIALLY good to see them come full circle and dance their first routine together as more developed dancers.
But, it kinda sucked that immediately after their dance, Sasha came up and Marko was eliminated. Sure, it’s not surprising and it was really sweet all around, but dude had to say his goodbyes standing in a toga. Not cool! Even if he wears it well. π
I thought it was sweet of Nigel to thank their lighting director and director. They have done a great job. Except whoever made the decision to end last night’s episode with the boys’ stepping routine. π And I quite agree with Nigel’s comment that the “lack of memorable routines” comment is a “load of crap,” after I spent all day re-watching routines from this season. And then, of course, re-watching them tonight just now. π
NOT a fan of Sonya’s District 78 Melanie/Sasha routine. Would’ve much rathered seen last night’s housewives routine, but I know it was last night, so it was pretty recent.
Oh my, here’s the big news….
MELANIE WON!!!! Oh my goodness, the girl from Marietta (like me!!!!) won Season 8!!!!
Who is the blond guy that was in the top 20 and now the boys top 10? I don’t recall there being a blond guy in the boys this season.
Lol I know I didn’t recognize him either but its alexander
@Lynn and Lauren: I know! I didn’t recognize him either! I even thought some of the All-Stars were dancing with them. Since I couldn’t actually COUNT the number of dancers with all the comings and goings, that was easy to believe. π
lol, was wondering too. pretty sure that was alex that had very dark hair but is now bleached blond.
i know i’m spoiling it for myself but i have a work thing tonight π
robert had to say his goodbyes in his bollywood outfit, lol, but I think the toga wins π love marko!!
Not Surprised of the first 2results… But still that Performance Finale episode … those two dancers took a toll on that final ruoutine last night… bad Choreography I guess…. I really hope melanie wins
ooop melanie did just win.. great
Does anyone know what song was played during Melanie and Sasha’s montage at the end?
@qwerty: It’s Hurts’ “Illuminated.” I can’t find a link at the moment. Here’s the YouTube video:
pretty amazing it took us 8 seasons to have an all-girls final 2
If my math is right, the votes for Melanie (47%) and Sasha (32%) left only 21% to be divided between Marko and Tadd. The girls did dominate.
My wife said something interesting when Melanie was announced as the winner – that she was very deserving, and she couldn’t find a reason to not like her except the hype she continually received from the first episode. But that wasn’t Melanie’s doing, and she can’t be blamed either for getting perhaps the key routines/choreography. Overall, we think she is a very deserving champion. Let’s see when we see her a year from now how much she’s matured, like LoFro has. (Much more raw power, and her legs especially are more powerful.)
@Margaret: That’s a really good point. I’ve gotten pretty cynical, so I wonder if Mr. Executive Producer Nigel Lythgoe et al stacked the deck for the girls this season because of the female bloodbath last season before LoFro finally one. But, beyond that cynical conspiracy theory thought, I’m VERY HAPPY about the result and the quality of the dancers. They’re incredible.
@Lee: The boys didn’t stand a chance this season. :)- I’m sure they producers were determined to overcorrect after last season’s early elimination of most of the girls, so they cast the strongest girls they could. I think Melanie really deserves to win (and so did Sasha, it was phenomenal Top 2), but even I was grossed out by all the hype. NOT her fault though and I love how humble and overwhelmed she was. π
i knew from day one it would come down to Melanie and Sasha! though i more a Sasha fan…..im Happy Melanie won!
This season left me cold. Appeared to be more about the judges (the more there are, the more talking, talking, talking) and less about the dancers. I felt sorry for the kids.
RB i agree…..same with season 6!
“The boys didnβt stand a chance this season. π – Iβm sure they producers were determined to overcorrect after last seasonβs early elimination of most of the girls” -@Emilie
The producers was very successful in doing so… I mean watching the finale for like 5 times. my GOD I wonder what was on the mind of the why producers put that Last number there… It was so wrong. any ways. I lOve this season on the first half of it at least…
I thought they did a veyr nice job (better than most seasons) of picking my favorite routines of the season for the finale.
I’ll disagree with Emile – I liked both of the Sonya pieces, and enjoyed the Melanie/Sasha dance they chose much better than last night’s.
@Kevin: I agree they did a great job of picking routines I really loved. The last one was the only one I didn’t LOVE. I’m glad to see people who do love it, it helps me understand it a bit better. π
Based on my opinion(not much but its mine) Melanie had more passion in her routines which desereved the win, buuuuuuuuuuuut, Tadd and Marko(even Sasha) had more technical skills. (I’m not an expert its just my opinion).
an interesting nugget of info, the last time an original partnership made the final 4 before melanie and marko was season 4 with Katee and Joshua, and they ended up in the same places and M&M, with Katee 3rd and Joshua 1st.
that was really the last time an enduring partnership happened on the show, kinda cool right?
@Margaret: That’s cool, thanks for reminding us about that!
I miss season 4 and even season 7…something about this season was strange. It was nice to see nick again. I wish he hadn’t been voted off so early. Bad luck I suppose.
I’m watching the show in bits and pieces now, Tadd’s elimination video is so sweet, he comes off totally different than he did in his interview w/ Cat last night.
and I really like how they’re have each finalist say a little something about each other. For all the grief we’ve had w/ this season, it’s nice to be reminded of what amazing friends these kids have become.
can’t wait to see them on tour!!
@Lauren, I totally agree about Nick, that tap number was fabulous!!! I could have done with less Woo-Man and more Nick, he’s adorable!
@lauren – I agree. That was a great tap number. And his quickstep and Bollywood were pretty good as well. Wish we’d seem more of him.
I am so happy with this season. Sad that Sasha didn’t win. Originally I was a Melanie fan but Sasha won me over. Were my eyes playing tricks on me or was that Sasha’s boob exposed while waiting to see who won????
MEL A NIE! MEL A NIE!
I knew from her first audition that she would make it. She is a technical MONSTER and can dance any style. Sasha was good but cannot dance in shoes (as evidenced by her last Bway routine) and the guys were great but didn’t come close technically to Melanie. A well deserved win!!!
Also, any idea who choreographed the tap number? It was amazing!
@Margaret #23. another interesting thing also in relation to season 4. the top 4 dancers then were color/ethnicity 2 male African/American, the girls were Asian and brunette white . in season 8 we Have 2 male Asians (Both of indo-malay ethnicity, Filipinos to exact), we have Melanie white, brunette again, and Sasha, African/American.
It was so interesting to see the UK’s favorite dancer was an amazing tapper (and looked a little long in the tooth which was cool).
Take note USA. Enough with the cry me a river, young, contemporary dancers.
let’s get some VARIETY in our top 4!
the US show hasn’t had a ballroom dancer in the top 4 since Benji and Heidi from 2006 and Lacey from 2007.
highlight of last night’s show was Nick, Jess and UK winner’s incredible tapping piece!
Actually @iluvpasha/anya , Ryan & Ashleigh Di Lello both are ballroom and both made it to the finale in season 6!
@Glory- i think S 6 final 4 were- Russell, Jakob, Kathryn, and Ellenore.
right but that year they had a finale 6 in the finale and the 5 and 6 were Ryan and Ashlieigh!!
Love your blog! I’m so happy that there is a place I can go to get other people’s opinions and insider info about the show. I also love that you post the songs! I’m happy that there are people who appreciate this show and the magical performances it gives us. My DVR is filled with the past 4 seasons. I can’t seem to bring myself to delete my favorite dances. Why can’t these come out on DVD! Anyways, I just wanted to say thanks for the blog and keep it up!!
@iluvpasha/anya, Glory was right, the De Lillos made it to the finally, season 6 had 6 contestants in the finals rather than a usual top 4
what was complete name of the song or artist for Hollow i thnk that was the title by hensley? they played it last night i want to buy on i tunes but cant find it…it was great song
I’m a total sasha fan! I’m glad melanie won though! Girls rule! π
@Nicole: no DVD due to song rights/restrictions (in other words, lots more $$$ for the DVD rights)
too bad the argentine tango was not live, but it was the same watching it for us!
the tapping was incredible, but i think my fav of the night was the top 10 boys routine. and alexander should not have dyed his hair.
anyways, you know how last season the judges said that nappytabs were the star choreographers? well i think this season’s was sonya tayeh. as weird as she is and can be, she is a phenomenal choreographer.
very pleased with the results!
@Kim and Nicole
I understand that song rights/restrictions are also the reason that there are no Tour DVDs as well (after the fact). It would be interesting to see if they (Nigel et al) could make a DVD financially reasonable – I think it would sell very well!
NICK YOUNG FTW! Should’ve stayed WAY longer.
@Kim (#27): Amanda (and Wikipedia) says the guys choreographed themselves, which makes that performance ALL the more impressive. π
@iluvpasha (#29): I agree that the US version needs more variety (everyone’s contemporary! or jazz, but same difference really). I think we need to have an All Country SYTYCD show down and pick some of the best and most-loved contestants from around the world and do a World’s Favorite Dancer. π
@Nicole (#33): Thanks! I’m so glad you like the site. We do it for people just like you who want to talk about the show and who are dying for the music. So it always makes me feel good to hear the work is appreciated. π
@sandi: (#35): What performance or segment of the show did it play during? All of the music can be found here, if that helps: https://puresytycd.com/tag/sytycd-music/
@Tink (#36): I agree! As corny as it sounds, I agree with Nigel that the only winner is dance. I always loved watching Sasha dance, especially when she had chemistry with her partner (which tended to be All-Stars, incidentally). I’m glad those two beasts were in the Top 2 together. π
@Kim and Lee (#37 and #39)): Yeah, it’s sad that licensing the music for DVDs would be so expensive because I know there are a lot of fans out there who’d like to be able to watch the season again (all of it, in order, the way we first watched it).
@maddy (#38): I think you’re right about Sonya being the star choreographer this season. π
@buggy (#40): I KNOW! Looking back through the videos to make my favorite dance list and watching that incredible tap routine in the finale made me wish SOOO MUCH that Nick had lasted longer in the competition. Seriously!
thanks emilie-worlds favorite dancer sounds perfect!
off topic- as the male lead for Dirty Dancing 2.0, I can only see Channing Tatum from Step Up and hope to see SYTYCD alumni as backup (Lacey, Pasha…)
@iluvpasha/anya: I’m glad you liked the idea. Now if we can only get Nigel et al to agree and make the show! I would NOT complain if Channing (nicest guy ever, by the way) were the new Johnny Castle. Maks, either. I looove Maks. BUT, a big part of my heart wants to see a big SYTYCD-alum cast. π